Fulton County has now admitted that 315,000 early votes in the 2020 election were never lawfully certified. The admission came during a December 9, 2025 State Election Board hearing, where county representatives stated they “do not dispute” that required signatures were missing from the tabulator tapes. Those votes determined the outcome of both U.S. Senate races in Georgia.
According to the hearing transcript and documentation submitted by election-integrity researcher David Cross, Fulton County failed to produce signed tabulator tapes for 148 scanners used during early voting. Georgia law requires poll managers and designated witnesses to sign each tape to certify the accuracy of the count. Without those signatures, the votes recorded on those machines were never certified.
Cross’s records document the scope of the violation. His open-records requests show 315,000 early votes tied to unsigned tapes. He identified 148 unsigned tabulator tapes across Fulton County’s early voting operation.
Ten additional tapes remain missing entirely. These tapes have been unaccounted for for more than a year. The missing documentation compounds the certification failure.
Cross documented systematic irregularities beyond the missing signatures. Timestamps show tapes printed at 11 p.m., midnight, 1 a.m., and 2 a.m. Scanner serial numbers were duplicated, indicating memory cards were moved between machines.
Zero tapes were missing from the chain of custody. Cross testified that hundreds of similar cases statewide remain unresolved. Fulton County did not contest any of these findings.
The State Election Board voted unanimously to refer the case to the Attorney General. The vote was 3–0. Civil penalties now await determination.
Georgia Rule 183-1-12-.12 establishes the certification requirement. Poll managers and witnesses must sign each tabulator tape at the close of voting. The signatures certify that the machine’s count is accurate and that chain-of-custody procedures were followed.
Unsigned tapes do not meet the statutory requirement for certification. The rule contains no exception for missing signatures. Fulton County’s 315,000 early votes were counted despite failing to meet this legal standard.
Georgia law does not provide a mechanism to retroactively decertify an election. State courts have ruled consistently on this point. The United States Senate, however, operates under Article I, Section 5 of the Constitution, which grants each chamber authority to judge the elections and qualifications of its members.
The 315,000 uncertified votes were included in Georgia’s official results. Those votes shaped both Senate races. The mathematical impact is definitive.
David Perdue received 49.7 percent in November 2020. Jon Ossoff received 47.9 percent. Georgia law requires a majority to win outright.
Without Fulton County’s uncertified early vote, Perdue exceeds the 50 percent threshold. No runoff would have occurred. Perdue would have won the seat in November.
The special election followed the same pattern. Kelly Loeffler and Raphael Warnock competed in a 20-candidate field. Warnock finished first with 32.9 percent based on Fulton County’s early vote surge.
Remove the uncertified votes, and Warnock’s margin collapses. He does not advance to the runoff. Loeffler becomes the top finisher among Republican candidates.
Both Senate seats would have been won in November by Republican candidates. The January 5, 2021 runoffs would not have occurred. Two different senators would represent Georgia today.
Those two seats gave Democrats control of the Senate. The margin was 50–50. Vice President Kamala Harris cast tie-breaking votes.
That control lasted from January 2021 through January 2023. During those two years, Democrats shaped judicial confirmations, federal spending, and the legislative agenda. The Biden administration’s policy direction depended on Senate control.
Ossoff’s term continues through 2027. Warnock faces reelection in 2028. If he wins, his term extends through 2035.
The Senate has acted repeatedly when elections were compromised. Historical precedent establishes the Senate’s authority. Three cases demonstrate the pattern.
William A. Clark resigned in 1900 after a committee found his election was secured through bribery. The Senate Committee on Privileges and Elections documented systematic vote-buying. Clark resigned before the full Senate could vote on expulsion.
Truman Newberry resigned in 1922 despite being declared duly elected. The Supreme Court had overturned his campaign finance conviction. But the cloud over his election made continued service untenable.
William Scott Vare was denied his seat in 1929 after the Senate found pervasive election corruption. The committee documented thousands of fraudulent registrations and padded voter rolls. The Senate voted to refuse him the seat he had won.
In each case, the issue was not personal guilt. The question was the legitimacy of the election process. The Senate refused to seat members whose elections violated fundamental standards.
The Senate retains full authority to investigate the 2020 Georgia Senate elections under Article I, Section 5. The Committee on Privileges and Elections can subpoena witnesses. The committee can examine the uncertified votes and determine whether the outcomes were legitimate.
Senators may also choose to step down voluntarily and call for special elections. This path allows Georgia voters to decide their representation in a lawful process. History shows which choice preserves honor.
For Senator Warnock, the implications extend beyond politics. As senior pastor of Ebenezer Baptist Church, he is held to the biblical standard of being above reproach. Holding a Senate seat obtained through uncertified votes places his pastoral credibility in conflict with the requirements of his office.
Scripture establishes the standard for church leaders. They must be blameless, sober, and above reproach. First Timothy and Titus make this requirement explicit.
James 3:1 adds a specific warning for teachers. “Not many of you should become teachers, my brothers, for you know that we who teach will be judged with greater strictness.” The standard is not whether Warnock personally committed wrongdoing.
The standard is whether he can continue in public office without the cloud of uncertified votes undermining his moral authority. A pastor who preaches integrity while holding a seat obtained through unlawfully certified votes faces a crisis of credibility. Every sermon carries questions about the legitimacy of his position.
The record is clear on what occurred. Fulton County counted 315,000 votes in 2020 that were never lawfully certified. County officials admitted this violation before the State Election Board.
The State Election Board confirmed the violation and referred the matter to the Attorney General. Cross’s documentation is extensive and uncontested. The consequences of those uncertified votes reshaped national policy for two years and continue to shape it today.
What remains is for the beneficiaries of that unlawful certification to decide whether they will uphold the integrity of the offices they hold. The choice will define their legacies.
Support Independent Local Journalism — High Country Advocate was created as a real alternative to regional media that too often silences dissenting voices while taking sides in the political struggle. Producing in-depth, unflinching reporting like this series and others is expensive: servers, editing, research time, and legal review all add up quickly. If these articles have informed you or given you new perspective, please consider supporting HCA with a paid subscription — every subscriber helps keep this reporting strong and independent. 