Aspen City Council unanimously continued the Aspen Meadows affordable housing hearing to a special April 20 meeting after the Aspen Center for Physics agreed during Tuesday’s session to eliminate all proposed housing units near North Street — including a revised placement on 6th Street — addressing objections raised across multiple hearings but leaving the Music Festival’s proposed 4th Street vehicle entrance unresolved. The March 24 meeting also saw council give unanimous first reading approval to Aspen Valley Hospital’s separate 60-unit workforce housing project at 1301 East Cooper Avenue, adopt the state-mandated Colorado Wildfire Resiliency Code on second reading, approve the Lumberyard project’s first financial closing documents, and pass a $48.5 million spring budget supplement.
Meadows Hearing Continued to April 20
The joint application by the Aspen Institute, Aspen Music Festival and School, and Aspen Center for Physics for housing across their Meadows campus drew nearly an hour of public comment before council closed the hearing and began deliberations at 9:09 p.m.
Physics Center Board Chair Josh Frieman presented revised plans earlier in the evening, reducing the center’s proposed beds from 63 to 55 by eliminating two of three North Street buildings and relocating a third unit closer to Smart Hall with a 6th Street driveway. After council members said the 6th Street relocation remained problematic, Frieman offered to remove that building entirely. “Our proposal would be to just eliminate that unit. We will not move it somewhere else. We would just remove it,” he said.
Design Workshop principal Jessica Garrow, representing all three applicants, said the Physics Center revision preserves the existing trail easement along North Street. The Music Festival separately committed to coordinating with city engineering on all access points and to adding crosswalk infrastructure at Gillespie and 4th streets.
The issue carrying into April 20 is the Music Festival’s proposal to route vehicles into its parking lot via 4th Street rather than 3rd Street. Councilmember Doyle said the 4th Street access “is the one thing that is problematic about this proposal.” Councilmember Rose said a dedicated bike-pedestrian way might be the most reasonable solution. Councilmember Benedetti said council had signaled across previous hearings that all three North Street units should go, and pressed for removal of the 6th Street unit as well, adding that the 4th Street question requires resolution before any approval.
Transportation consultant Terri Partch of Jacobs Engineering presented data showing pedestrian traffic concentrates on 3rd and 5th streets during events rather than 4th Street, and argued that narrower streets tend to slow drivers. Residents disputed those conclusions in public comment.
West End residents questioned whether Physics Center housing qualifies as affordable housing given that participants stay two to three weeks at a time. “These are transient two and three week stays — hotel stays,” said Lisa Markalunas, a fourth-generation Aspen native. “They’re not people who are long-term members of this community.” Val Stevenson noted the Physics Center represents 56 percent of the total housing request while housing no full-time employees.
Ryan Dougherty, attorney for the 4th Street Pedestrian Preservation Coalition, argued the Music Festival’s 4th Street access plan does not meet fire code width standards and that the land use code requires council to make infrastructure findings now, not defer them to detailed review. Attorney Curtis Sanders, representing Bear Alley LLC at 775 Meadows Road, read a letter from the property’s owners urging the Institute to site housing closer to existing campus density.
A 4th Street homeowner said the existing 22-foot-wide street cannot accommodate two standard SUVs passing simultaneously and raised fire department access concerns. A West End resident questioned whether APCHA deed restrictions on Physics units — which carry fee waivers normally reserved for workforce housing — should apply to short-term participant stays. Colleen Collins, an online commenter, said the Music Festival’s parking plan lacks enforcement and that Gillespie Street is bearing too much of the project’s traffic impact.
Councilmember Guth raised during deliberations whether calling Physics Center units affordable housing is appropriate, since that classification triggers fee waivers he said should be reserved for year-round workforce housing. City Attorney Katharine Johnson suggested the ordinance could be drafted to require deed restrictions on use and rental rates without triggering affordable housing fee waivers — an approach council agreed to develop before April 20.
Rather than deny the application — which under the land use code would bar a similar application for one year — council voted 5-0 to continue the hearing.
Hospital Housing Wins Unanimous First Reading
Council voted 5-0 to advance Aspen Valley Hospital’s 60-unit affordable housing project at 1301 East Cooper Avenue — the former Crestahaus Lodge, now called the Beaumont property — to second reading on April 14.
The project would demolish existing structures and replace them with 57 one-bedroom and three two-bedroom units across seven buildings, with 59 parking spaces, on the 53,543-square-foot parcel. Rezoning from R-15 to Residential Multi-Family is required.
Principal Planner Jeffrey Barnhill said the hospital, as a political subdivision with taxing authority, holds unique legal standing — if council denies the rezoning, the hospital board could authorize construction regardless with a two-thirds vote. Planning and Zoning Commission recommended approval 4-2 on March 4.
Council requested density comparisons to similar city projects, a complete transportation plan, workforce impact data, specifics on the two dissenting P&Z votes, headlight and landscaping protections for neighboring properties, and confirmation that a six-month minimum lease requirement is written into the ordinance. Forty-five of the 60 units fall below minimum APCHA square footage standards even with allowable reductions, requiring special review at second reading.
Wildfire Code Adopted
Council unanimously adopted the Colorado Wildfire Resiliency Code on second reading, meeting the April 1 state deadline. The code applies to new construction and larger alterations, requiring structure hardening against ember penetration and a five-foot noncombustible perimeter around buildings. Code enforcement takes effect at the end of July.
Chief Building Official Bonnie Muhigirwa said most structure hardening requirements have been in Aspen’s building code since 2023. Staff recommended applying the highest protection level citywide despite the city’s urban designation on state maps. “The city is completely surrounded by high and moderate risk properties,” Muhigirwa said. During public comment, resident Gloria Crystal asked where people should go in a fire. Mayor Richards said the Aspen Fire District’s website outlines recommendations by location and that RFTA will coordinate evacuations under incident command for residents without vehicles.
Lumberyard Financial Closing Approved
Council voted 5-0 to approve the first set of Lumberyard financial closing documents, including a ground lease, operating agreement, construction license, and APCHA-approved deed restriction. Capital Asset Director Rob Schober and Kimball Crangle of Gorman & Company presented. Buildings 2 and 3 are expected to begin construction in approximately one year, overlapping with Building 1 still under construction. City protections include consent rights over any management transfer, biannual financial reports, and oversight triggers if reserves fall below designated thresholds.
A separate resolution amending Lumberyard lottery priorities to allow transfers from APCHA ownership units to Lumberyard rentals passed 4-1, with Guth dissenting. “It’s not in the community’s best interest to incentivize people moving out of ownership units unless downsizing, and this is not limited to downsizing only,” Guth said.
Budget Supplement and Pool Contract
Council adopted the 2026 spring budget supplement on second reading 5-0, increasing total spending authority by $48.5 million — primarily $34.6 million in capital project reauthorizations carried from 2025 and $3.8 million in departmental savings. New requests total $189,405. Finance Director Tyler Sexton reported three adjustments since first reading produced a net reduction of approximately $138,000.
The $4,211,570 recreation center pool repair contract with PNCI Construction passed 4-1, with Guth dissenting. The project runs June through September. Guth argued the city should advance outdoor pool planning simultaneously to avoid closing pools twice. Recreation Director Desiree Whitehead responded that the outdoor pool concept from 2008 lacks construction drawings needed to proceed.
Aspen Area Community Trust, Other Actions
Council voted 4-1 to acknowledge the incorporation of the Aspen Area Community Trust and authorize $35,000 in additional funding for consultant support and an IRS 501(c)(3) application, with Guth dissenting on the expenditure while supporting the concept. Community Development Director Ben Anderson said AACT is an independent nonprofit focused on preserving affordable commercial space for locally-serving businesses. Board member Ann Mullins said the organization grew from an idea she first brought to council in 2013, developed further with a 2023 DOLA feasibility grant of $135,000.
Council voted 5-0 to grant a 2027 long-time local demolition allotment to John “LJ” Erspamer for his Spruce Street duplex, which he has owned since 1990. All 2026 allotments were exhausted through prior appeals.
During citizens comments at the meeting’s outset, resident Francis Stuckins raised trail safety concerns, saying a coworker had been pushed off his bike in a near-miss near Centennial employee housing. Mayor Richards said RFTA, Pitkin County, and the Parks Department are collaborating on trail safety and e-bike management.
Consent calendar approvals included an APCHA spring budget supplemental of approximately $1.48 million, Wrights Road Waterline Project change orders increasing the project total to $4 million, a trails asphalt resurfacing contract ($306,439, Frontier Paving), an enterprise GIS cloud services contract ($400,000 over three years, ROK Technologies), and concrete replacement and ADA improvements ($446,977).
Board Reports and Proclamation
Councilmember Doyle shared Protect Our Winters data showing heat records have outpaced cold records 2-to-1 nationally since 1999 and read from the wildfire resiliency memo that Aspen and Pitkin County are in exceptional drought with snowpack at 66 percent of median as of March 12. Colorado recorded its warmest winter in 131 years. Doyle reported the state is activating its drought task force immediately and fire season is now year-round. Mayor Richards urged residents to complete Aspen Fire District surveys to improve fire spread modeling accuracy and practice water conservation.
The Chris Klug Foundation presented an organ donor month proclamation. Klug, a 25-year liver transplant recipient, recognized donor families present and noted Colorado was previously the top donor-registration state in the country.
Support Independent Local Journalism — High Country Advocate was created as a real alternative to regional media that too often silences dissenting voices while taking sides in the political struggle. Producing in-depth, unflinching reporting like this series and others is expensive: servers, editing, research time, and legal review all add up quickly. If these articles have informed you or given you new perspective, please consider supporting HCA with a paid subscription — every subscriber helps keep this reporting strong and independent. 