BUENA VISTA — The Board of Trustees approved a $2 million public improvement agreement with the developer behind a new City Market, awarded a contract for a comprehensive water rate study, and activated a long-dormant airport design review committee at its April 28 regular meeting. The board also ratified a co-responder mental health program agreement with the Chaffee County Sheriff’s Office and heard a resident’s call for stronger enforcement of the town’s leash laws after a violent dog attack.
Mayor Libby Fay presided. All six trustees were present: Mayor Pro Tem Devin Rowe and Trustees Maggie Huyck, Cindie Swisher, Andrew Rice, Micha Rosenoer, and Chris Sturm. The meeting was called to order at 7 p.m. at the Community Center, 715 E. Main Street.
City Market Infrastructure Agreement
The board approved a public improvement agreement with Dillon Companies, LLC — City Market’s parent company — requiring the developer to fund and construct $2,025,976 in public infrastructure tied to the new store’s Crossman Avenue development. Planning Director Marika Kopp presented the agreement, which covers road improvements on Farwell Avenue, a new traffic signal, sidewalks, drainage infrastructure, and utilities.
The developer must pay 100 percent of construction costs and post a financial guarantee equal to 115 percent of the estimated total. The town withholds the certificate of occupancy until all public improvements are complete and passes a two-year warranty period, after which the town assumes ownership.
Discussion focused on a sidewalk gap along the Highway 24 frontage that City Market is not required to fill. Planning Director Kopp said an adjacent O’Reilly’s development currently under review will close part of that gap, and that the remaining gap near a restaurant on the corner remains a priority for staff. Trustees also raised concerns about a private underground stormwater infiltration basin on the property. The town attorney advised that standard nuisance provisions allow enforcement if the basin fails to function, and suggested the board consider requiring drainage easements from future developers as a stronger long-term tool. Galloway Engineering’s Joe Park, attending by phone, confirmed the basin is designed to handle a 100-year storm event and includes inspection ports. The board adopted Resolution 2026-36 unanimously.
Water Rate Study
The board voted unanimously — by roll call — to award the 2026 Water Rate Study and Financial Plan to SwiftWater Solutions, LLC, approving Resolution 2026-35. Public Works Director Shawn Williams said the town received two qualified proposals and recommended SwiftWater based on the firm’s prior work with Buena Vista, including the town’s recently adopted Water Conservation Plan.
A SwiftWater Solutions representative explained the study will evaluate current rate accuracy, develop a 10-year financial plan, and recommend a tiered, conservation-oriented rate structure in which heavier water users pay progressively higher rates. He noted the core challenge: encouraging conservation reduces consumption, which reduces the revenue needed to maintain infrastructure. The study is scoped to address that balance.
Trustees asked that the study include comparative data from other Colorado mountain towns. Joel Benson, the town’s senior policy advisor, said an Urban Land Institute grant will bring six to ten water policy experts to Buena Vista in September for a roundtable on tiered rate structures, and that SwiftWater’s findings and the roundtable results are intended to complement each other.
Airport Design Review Committee
The board adopted Resolution 2026-31, appointing Airport Advisory Board members Chris Mertes, Ted Osowski, Mark Russell, and Mike Allen to a newly constituted Airport Design Review Committee. The committee is required under a 2009 municipal code provision to govern development approvals at the airport — a requirement that had never been formally implemented.
The town attorney explained the committee carries quasi-judicial authority, making binding decisions on development applications at the airport, with appeals going directly to the board of trustees. Discussion centered on whether committee meetings should be public. The town attorney advised that at minimum, notices must be posted in advance under state sunshine law requirements, and that written findings of fact should accompany any approval or denial to support the record on appeal.
The board directed the newly seated committee to develop a formal statement of purpose, scope, and procedural guidelines and return with a report. Airport Manager Chandra Swanson was advised she should not serve as a voting member of the committee, as she reviews applications before forwarding them to it for final action. The motion passed unanimously.
Airport Advisory Board Function and Focus
Airport Advisory Board Chair Chris Mertes and member Mike Allen presented the board’s inaugural 2026 Function and Focus document. Mertes said the board’s primary goal is to support town and airport staff in preparing for development and expansion at the Central Colorado Regional Airport, where all hangars are full and a waiting list exists. He said the board’s volunteer expertise could produce a preliminary development layout plan — work that would otherwise require an expensive engineering contract.
Trustee Rice, serving as the board’s airport liaison, said a formal airport master plan is financially out of reach but that the advisory board’s expertise fills that gap. Airport staff noted that development interest exceeds what the airport’s existing infrastructure can serve, and that an annexation proposal to bring the full airport — which currently straddles the town and county line — under a single jurisdiction is anticipated later this year. No board action was required on the presentation.
Airport Ground Lease — Hangar C-1
The board terminated an existing ground lease for Hangar C-1 at the Central Colorado Regional Airport and approved a new 25-year ground lease with Wes Erickson and his company, Arc Valley Hangar LLC, effective May 1, under Resolution 2026-33. The lease includes two 10-year renewal options. Airport staff noted this is the first ground lease executed on the town’s new template. The motion passed unanimously.
FAA Entitlement Transfer to Cortez
By unanimous roll call vote, the board adopted Resolution 2026-34, transferring fiscal year 2024 and 2026 FAA Airport Improvement Program entitlement funds from the Central Colorado Regional Airport to Cortez Municipal Airport. Airport staff described it as a routine reciprocal arrangement among four Colorado airports, tracked by the FAA to ensure entitlements are returned when the originating airport has eligible projects.
Co-Responder Program MOU
The board approved a memorandum of understanding formalizing Buena Vista’s participation in the Chaffee County Sheriff’s Office Co-Responder Program, which pairs mental health clinicians with law enforcement on applicable calls. The town contributed $32,000 to the program in 2026 — roughly half the amount originally requested — with the balance covered by Chaffee County and opioid settlement funds recently awarded to the county.
The MOU mirrors the agreement between the county and the City of Salida, creating uniform operational rules across participating jurisdictions. It requires annual review of Buena Vista’s contribution in the second quarter of each year. Williams said the review timeline can be adjusted administratively to align with the town’s budget cycle. The motion passed unanimously.
Leesmeagh Ditch Water Lease Amendment
The board adopted Resolution 2026-32, approving a third amendment to the town’s raw water lease with Meadows Farm LLC for water from the Leesmeagh Ditch. The town has held the water right — one dating to 1864 — since 1974, keeping it in active beneficial use on a Crossman Avenue farm property. The amendment adds provisions for periods when instream flow requirements for fish and wildlife prevent irrigation: if the ditch runs dry for 30 to 60 consecutive days, Meadows Farm receives a 50 percent refund on the annual lease fee; 60 or more days triggers a full refund. The annual lease amount is approximately $120. The motion passed unanimously.
Water Advisory Board Function and Focus
A Water Advisory Board member presented the board’s 2026 Function and Focus document in the absence of chair Kelly Collins, who is relocating for medical reasons. The document outlines goals including advancing the town’s Water Conservation Plan, updating source water protection regulations, completing water distribution system modeling, and coordinating with the U.S. Forest Service and the Upper Arkansas Water Conservancy District. A trustee praised Collins’s leadership of the board. No action was required.
Consent Agenda
The board adopted the consent agenda, which included minutes from the April 14 Board of Trustees meeting, the March 18 Recreation Advisory Board meeting, and the April 1 Planning and Zoning Commission meeting, along with routine reports from the town administrator, town treasurer, airport manager, and recreation director. The consent agenda also included Resolution 2026-30, appointing Wes Erickson as a regular voting member of the Airport Advisory Board. A trustee asked that future committee meeting summaries identify the author; staff noted the short-term rental committee notes in the packet were prepared by facilitator Katie Davis. The consent agenda passed unanimously.
Public Comment — Dog Enforcement
A Buena Vista resident addressed the board during public comment, describing a December 15, 2025 attack in which two pit bulls came after her child while she was running in town. She said the dogs had attacked another family days earlier but were returned to their owner rather than impounded, despite a town ordinance requiring removal of aggressive dogs from town limits. The attack left her unable to run and resulted in medical bills and an active criminal investigation against the dog’s owner.
She asked the board to raise the town’s $50 off-leash fine — half of what Chaffee County charges — and to implement escalating penalties for repeat offenders and citation-based enforcement rather than verbal warnings. She said code enforcement staff spend one to two-thirds of their workload responding to off-leash dog complaints.
During trustee and staff interaction later in the meeting, the board returned to the issue. Trustees discussed the gap between verbal warnings and actual citations, and the broader problem of off-leash dogs, nuisance barking, and dogs escaping private property. A trustee proposed a work session with code enforcement to review enforcement data. The board discussed directing the police department to issue citations rather than warnings for off-leash violations. No formal vote was taken.
Trustee and Staff Interaction
Trustees noted several items from the town administrator’s report, including a Great Outdoors Colorado recognition and progress on a reduced-speed zone on Highway 24 where students cross. Town Treasurer Phillip Puckett received recognition from trustees for the finance department winning a budget award.
Trustee Rosenoer reported attending a Facing Water forum the prior week, where presenters said the 2026 water outlook may be drier than 2002 — the driest year in a 1,200-year tree ring record. Rosenoer said the Arkansas River is managed by many entities and that the summer will test those systems.
A trustee noted that the short-term rental committee is working toward a policy framework, with a fourth meeting being scheduled, and that a response to citizens and property owners who have written about the moratorium is appropriate once more direction is available.
A trustee mentioned the Arbor Day booth at the Splash Park, scheduled from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. in May, where the Tree Advisory Board will provide information on tree care and drought conditions. A trustee noted the new cemetery fence as a notable recent improvement.
Proclamation
Mayor Fay opened the meeting by reading a proclamation declaring May 2026 as Lyme and Other Tick-Borne Diseases Awareness Month, citing increasing tick exposure in Colorado and a December 2025 U.S. Department of Health and Human Services roundtable on improving diagnostics and patient-centered care. The board adopted the agenda as corrected — a staff member noted that Business Items A and B had been mislabeled as 2025 rather than 2026. The meeting adjourned unanimously.
Support Independent Local Journalism — High Country Advocate was created as a real alternative to regional media that too often silences dissenting voices while taking sides in the political struggle. Producing in-depth, unflinching reporting like this series and others is expensive: servers, editing, research time, and legal review all add up quickly. If these articles have informed you or given you new perspective, please consider supporting HCA with a paid subscription — every subscriber helps keep this reporting strong and independent. 

