By Vince Phillips
While Denver and Boulder celebrate their swelling census numbers and extra congressional seats, the rest of Colorado, especially rural counties like Chaffee, are left holding the bill. This is the ugly underbelly of gerrypandering.
The Financial Toll
Sanctuary policies and mass illegal immigration carry enormous costs. Denver alone has spent over $356 million on migrant services since 2022. Across the country, sanctuary jurisdictions have burned through tens of billions of dollars, much of it coming from federal taxpayers, including hardworking families in Chaffee County who never consented to any of it. These dollars don’t magically appear. They come from reduced services, higher taxes, or diverted funds that could have gone to roads, schools, and infrastructure in rural Colorado.
The Human Cost
- Overcrowded emergency rooms and longer wait times at hospitals
- Strained public schools trying to absorb large numbers of non-English speaking students
- Increased retail theft and property crime in cities that have softened enforcement
- Working families priced out of housing while government resources are redirected toward new arrivals
- Pressure on social services, food banks, and homeless programs
What This Looks Like in Chaffee County
We’re not a sanctuary county, yet we still pay the price. Every dollar funneled to Denver or Boulder for migrant support is a dollar that didn’t help maintain our roads, support our local schools, or keep property taxes from climbing.
Even more damaging, many long-time Chaffee residents, ranchers, working families, and multi-generational locals, are reluctantly leaving. They’re being priced out by skyrocketing taxes and housing costs, strangled by ever-increasing regulations, and worn down by a shifting cultural climate that no longer feels like home. Ranchers who have stewarded this land for generations now find themselves fighting policies that make it harder to operate while watching their children move away because they can’t afford to stay.
Some local leaders, including County Commissioner P.T. Wood, have expressed deep “outrage” over ICE enforcement actions and declared that “we value immigrants coming here, they are an essential part of the fabric of our community.” Fair enough.
But if our current federal immigration laws are so terrible and inhumane, one has to ask: When Democrats controlled the White House, the House, and the Senate from 2021 to 2023, why didn’t they overturn or fundamentally reform those laws? They had the power to fix the system they now claim is broken, and they chose not to.
The bitter irony is thick: politicians who loudly proclaim they are “preserving the character of the county” and “protecting our rural way of life” are, in the eyes of many locals, destroying it beyond repair. By driving out the very people who built and sustained Chaffee County and replacing them with newcomers more aligned with urban priorities, they are fundamentally changing the community, not through honest persuasion, but through economic and regulatory pressure.
That’s not preservation. That’s soft gerrypandering at the local level.
The Ultimate Irony
The politicians who wrap themselves in the language of compassion are creating victims on multiple sides:
- Rural Americans who lose political power and local services
- Legal immigrants and citizens who played by the rules
- Even many of the illegal migrants themselves, who are being used as political pawns in a power game
They assume we won’t connect the dots. But the pattern is unmistakable: Import a new electorate → Inflate the census → Gain more power and money → Use that power to double down on the same failed policies. This is gerrypandering in full bloom, and rural Colorado is paying a disproportionate share of the price, both financially and culturally.
Support Independent Local Journalism — High Country Advocate was created as a real alternative to regional media that too often silences dissenting voices while taking sides in the political struggle. Producing in-depth, unflinching reporting like this series and others is expensive: servers, editing, research time, and legal review all add up quickly. If these articles have informed you or given you new perspective, please consider supporting HCA with a paid subscription — every subscriber helps keep this reporting strong and independent.
