Colorado faces an $800 million budget shortfall. Legislators are debating cuts to Medicaid, higher education, and social services. Governor Polis slashed $250 million in August. The Joint Budget Committee warns more reductions are coming.
The problem is fixable. The money exists. State auditors have already found it.
Exposed fraud and waste across Colorado agencies totals more than $550 million in documented, recoverable funds. Add a 5% efficiency cut to non-essential spending — protecting K-12 and Medicaid — and the state generates another $340 million. That’s $890 million against an $800 million hole. No service cuts required. Under TABOR, the $90 million surplus goes back to Colorado taxpayers as refund checks.
The solution requires three actions: eliminate the documented fraud, sunset obsolete programs, and demand agency efficiency. Every dollar is accounted for. Every source is a state or federal audit. This isn’t theory. It’s arithmetic.
Start with fraud. Colorado’s unemployment system paid $73 million in fraudulent benefits during the pandemic. Dead people received $3.9 million. Prisoners got $5 million. Minors who couldn’t legally work collected $102,000. The state auditor flagged the failures. The Department of Labor acknowledged them. The money hasn’t been recovered.
The Department of Justice indicted seven people in 2024 for a $40 million Medicare and Medicaid scheme involving false genetic testing claims routed through Colorado labs. Medicaid transportation providers billed for phantom rides — trips that never happened, or patients routed to distant clinics to pad claims. The federal Office of Inspector General found Colorado paid $7.3 million to insurers for nearly 9,000 dead Medicaid enrollees, including 4,837 whose deaths were already in state systems. Colorado refused to refund the federal share.
Move to waste. CDOT paid $158.7 million for work on expired contracts — agreements that had legally ended but kept running. Another $18 million went to contractors who exceeded estimates. The Judicial Branch drew the auditor’s harshest findings: occupational fraud, apparently illegal transactions, misuse of public funds, all referred to law enforcement. Six sole-source contracts totaling $3.87 million lacked justification. One $2.5 million contract was flagged as potential hush money.
Agencies are hoarding cash in violation of state law. The Judicial Department holds $12.8 million in excess reserves. The Division of Professions and Occupations has $8 million in a fund out of compliance for six years. The Department of Early Childhood announced in January that 27,000 children would lose care without $91 million in emergency funds. Senator Barbara Kirkmeyer pointed out what the department failed to mention: it was sitting on $76 million in fund balances. “So poorly mismanaged,” Kirkmeyer said.
Obsolete programs keep drawing funds. The Title Insurance Commission made zero recommendations in seven years. The Veterinary Pharmaceutical Advisory Committee hasn’t met since 2021. DORA recommends eliminating these bodies. The legislature has the authority to act. It hasn’t.
The accounting failures suggest the waste runs deeper than auditors have yet uncovered. The Department of Local Affairs omitted $495 million from federal reporting. The Department of Labor overstated estimates by $266.2 million. The State Controller’s office had a $663.4 million misstatement. A 5% efficiency target is conservative given what remains unexamined.
Here is the path to a balanced budget with no service cuts:
Eliminate documented fraud and waste: $555 million. This requires recovering misspent funds, terminating programs that enabled the failures, and holding responsible parties accountable.
Sunset obsolete programs: Savings vary, but every dollar spent on a commission that hasn’t met in years is a dollar unavailable for services that matter.
Implement 5% efficiency cuts to non-essential spending: $340 million. Protect K-12 and Medicaid. Require every other agency to find efficiencies auditors haven’t yet documented.
Total available: $895 million. Shortfall: $800 million. Surplus: $95 million returned to taxpayers under TABOR.
The 2026 election is underway. Democrats control the governorship and both legislative chambers. They own this budget. The choice they face is straightforward: cut services and explain those cuts to voters, or eliminate waste and return the surplus.
One path requires defending reductions to Medicaid and higher education. The other requires explaining why the waste existed in the first place.
Colorado’s $800 million shortfall is not an unsolvable crisis. The audits are public. The failures are documented. The math works. The only missing ingredient is political will.
Support Independent Local Journalism — High Country Advocate was created as a real alternative to regional media that too often silences dissenting voices while taking sides in the political struggle. Producing in-depth, unflinching reporting like this series and others is expensive: servers, editing, research time, and legal review all add up quickly. If these articles have informed you or given you new perspective, please consider supporting HCA with a paid subscription — every subscriber helps keep this reporting strong and independent. 