Under Colorado law, a person does not have to live in Colorado to vote here. Residency, once established, persists until a voter re-registers somewhere else. That single legal fact explains much of what Secretary of State Jena Griswold has never fully accounted for in the state’s voter rolls.
Griswold’s office maintains 4,384,312 registered voters as of April 2024. The Census Bureau counts 4,390,366 Coloradans old enough to vote. The statewide gap looks manageable at 6,054. It isn’t.
The Census Bureau’s voting age population count includes an estimated 200,000 undocumented immigrants in Colorado, according to the Pew Research Center. Approximately 90 percent are working-age adults, putting an estimated 160,000 people in the VAP count who cannot legally register to vote. That inflates the benchmark used to measure Colorado’s rolls, meaning the true exceedances in each county are worse than the numbers show.
The statewide number also obscures what is happening county by county. Using Griswold’s own master voter file against Census Bureau age tables, nine of seventeen mountain and rural counties carry voter rolls exceeding their entire voting age population:
- Mineral County: population 729 — 998 registered voters, 643 VAP — 155.2%
- Archuleta County: population 13,900 — 12,955 registered voters, 11,579 VAP — 111.9%
- Custer County: population 5,247 — 4,983 registered voters, 4,528 VAP — 110.0%
- Park County: population 17,907 — 16,521 registered voters, 15,353 VAP — 107.6%
- Teller County: population 24,825 — 21,962 registered voters, 20,936 VAP — 104.9%
- Chaffee County: population 20,178 — 18,080 registered voters, 17,374 VAP — 104.1%
- Pitkin County: population 16,985 — 15,085 registered voters, 14,501 VAP — 104.0%
- Rio Grande County: population 11,321 — 9,300 registered voters, 9,040 VAP — 102.9%
- Lake County: population 7,380 — 6,076 registered voters, 6,011 VAP — 101.1%
Stripping out the two categories that inflate Colorado’s voter eligibility benchmark — the estimated 160,000 undocumented adults counted in the VAP who cannot legally register, and the 70,294 registered voters currently receiving ballots outside Colorado — produces an adjusted eligible voter pool of approximately 4,160,072. Colorado’s rolls of 4,384,312 exceed that number by roughly 224,000. That is HCA’s analysis based on Census, Pew Research Center, and Griswold’s own voter file. It represents the gap between who is registered and who should be eligible to register under Colorado and federal law.
Griswold’s standing answer is that Colorado law allows former residents to remain registered until they establish residency elsewhere. Students, military personnel, and retirees who moved away remain legal Colorado voters under state law. The Secretary of State’s own FAQ states that absence does not end residency.
That answer is legally accurate. It is also incomplete. It does not explain how a county’s rolls can exceed every adult who physically lives there. It does not address what portion of the 70,294 voters currently receiving Colorado ballots at out-of-state addresses moved away years ago, registered elsewhere, and were never removed from Colorado’s rolls.
Those 70,294 ballots go to real addresses. 54,007 land in other states — California leads with 6,107, followed by Texas with 5,503. Another 16,287 go abroad, reaching 130 countries including Canada, Germany, the United Kingdom, and Australia. Federal law bars Colorado from purging a voter for moving without completing a specific notice process. Griswold has pointed to that constraint repeatedly. What she has not explained is why the pace of removal consistently lags the pace of departure.
A federal court already examined that record. Judicial Watch sued Griswold in October 2020, alleging Colorado violated the National Voter Registration Act by failing to remove ineligible voters. The court allowed the case to proceed over Griswold’s objection. She settled in March 2023, denying all violations while agreeing to six years of mandatory roll-maintenance reporting to Judicial Watch. Roll removals had climbed 78 percent since the lawsuit was filed. Griswold called that normal post-election maintenance. The settlement, and what it required of her going forward, said otherwise.
That settlement covered rolls that predated this data. Nine counties in Colorado’s mountain corridor still show more registered voters than adults old enough to cast a ballot. The law Griswold administers created the conditions for it. The question her six-year reporting obligation has yet to answer is how many of those excess registrations belong to people who left Colorado, registered somewhere new, and are still on her rolls.
Support Independent Local Journalism — High Country Advocate was created as a real alternative to regional media that too often silences dissenting voices while taking sides in the political struggle. Producing in-depth, unflinching reporting like this series and others is expensive: servers, editing, research time, and legal review all add up quickly. If these articles have informed you or given you new perspective, please consider supporting HCA with a paid subscription — every subscriber helps keep this reporting strong and independent. 

