Two rulings landed in two days. On March 31, a federal judge told the Trump administration it cannot force Colorado to enforce immigration law. The day before, a state judge told Governor Jared Polis he cannot walk away from a lawsuit over whether he tried to hand ICE the same data those laws were written to protect.
U.S. District Judge Gordon P. Gallagher dismissed the Department of Justice’s lawsuit against Colorado and Denver on 10th Amendment grounds. He cited the Supreme Court’s 1997 anti-commandeering precedent and wrote that state participation in immigration enforcement is voluntary. Striking Colorado’s sanctuary laws would force the state to bear the cost of a federal program and strip its authority over its own resources. Federal judges in Illinois and New York had already dismissed identical DOJ lawsuits on the same grounds.
Four state statutes and two Denver ordinances survived. HB19-1124 barred officers from honoring civil immigration detainers. SB21-131 prohibited state employees from sharing personal information with ICE unless tied to a criminal investigation. HB23-1100 ended county jail contracts with ICE — killing Teller County’s detention agreement, which had paid the sheriff $93 per day per bed for up to 40 detainees. SB25-276 extended restrictions to schools, libraries, and clinics, with $50,000 penalties for violations. DOJ refiled with a more aggressive complaint last July after SB25-276 passed. Gallagher dismissed it anyway.
The day before Gallagher’s ruling, Denver District Judge A. Bruce Jones refused to dismiss Moss v. Polis. Scott Moss, former director of the Division of Labor Standards and Statistics at the Department of Labor, sued Polis last June after the governor ordered him to comply with an ICE administrative subpoena seeking personal information on 35 people sponsoring unaccompanied minor children. The subpoena was labeled “Immigration Enforcement Subpoena.” Polis argued it was tied to a human trafficking investigation. Jones rejected that argument and blocked the data release last June.
Polis then reversed. In early 2026 he asked Jones to permanently block the information and end the case, arguing ICE no longer needed it. Jones denied the request on March 30, calling it “untethered to any rule of procedure” and citing an “absence of any legal authority.”
On March 13 — one week before Polis’s lawyers told the judge another subpoena was unlikely — ICE sent a second, nearly identical subpoena to the same department. Moss’s attorney Laura Wolf obtained it through a records request after the governor’s legal team did not produce it. The labor department said this week it has not responded and is “working through” the governor’s new policy.
That policy took effect February 12. It requires all state agencies to route subpoena responses through the governor’s office and label all correspondence “privileged” — a designation that shields deliberations from the Colorado Open Records Act. Wolf called it a policy that gives the governor “unfettered authority on production decisions while shielding all such deliberations from scrutiny.” Jeff Roberts of the Colorado Freedom of Information Coalition said the subpoenas themselves remain accessible through records requests, but the internal discussions about compliance do not.
SB21-131 sits at the center of both cases. It is the law DOJ asked Gallagher to strike down. It is also the law Moss alleges the governor violated when he ordered compliance with ICE’s subpoena. Gallagher confirmed it is constitutional. Jones is deciding whether the governor followed it.
Both rulings reach into HCA territory. DOJ’s amended complaint last July targeted Attorney General Phil Weiser’s lawsuit against Mesa County Deputy Alexander Zwinck, who shared information with ICE about a 19-year-old nursing student during a traffic stop. ICE detained the student for two weeks. Gallagher’s ruling means the law Weiser enforced against Zwinck stands. In Teller County, HB23-1100 ended the sheriff’s ICE detention contract and Gallagher confirmed the legislature had the authority to terminate it.
Moss’s lawyers will depose the governor before mediation scheduled for mid-April. HB26-1276, moving through the legislature, would require state agencies to publish ICE subpoenas and notify individuals whose data gets shared. DOJ has 30 days to appeal to the 10th Circuit.
Support Independent Local Journalism — High Country Advocate was created as a real alternative to regional media that too often silences dissenting voices while taking sides in the political struggle. Producing in-depth, unflinching reporting like this series and others is expensive: servers, editing, research time, and legal review all add up quickly. If these articles have informed you or given you new perspective, please consider supporting HCA with a paid subscription — every subscriber helps keep this reporting strong and independent. 

