By Vince Phillips
A recent letter to the editor in a Salida newspaper has left me troubled. The writer, a conscientious objector, argues that those who served, or support those who serve, are somehow morally compromised for following orders in wars he considers illegal or immoral. He suggests that refusing to serve showed greater courage and a clearer conscience than those who answered the call.
I did not serve in the military. I have respect for the conscientious objector status. If a person truly cannot, in good faith, take up arms, I don’t want them in the foxhole next to those who need to rely on their brothers in arms. An unwilling or resentful soldier is a danger to everyone around him. That much the letter writer and I can agree on.
But the piece goes much further. It doesn’t just defend the right to object. It sits in judgment on every American who put on the uniform during Vietnam, Iraq, or any conflict the author deems unjust. In his words: “Those who participated in these illegal wars can never wash the blood from their hands or their souls.” This is where the argument collapses.
War is never clean. Bad decisions get made at the top. Intelligence is sometimes wrong. Politicians lie. The Gulf of Tonkin and the Iraq WMD claims are fair examples of that. But the 19-year-old on the ground does not have the full picture. He is not privy to the same intelligence, diplomatic cables, or strategic calculations possessed by the chain of command. When that young man is given a lawful order, his duty is to carry it out. That is not blind obedience. That is how a military functions. Without it, you have chaos, friendly fire, and dead Americans.
The letter suggests soldiers should have simply refused “illegal orders.” That sounds noble in a coffee shop in Howard, Colorado. In the real world it gets people killed. You cannot have an army where every private gets to play philosopher and decide which missions he personally approves. The alternative is not moral purity. It is anarchy.
I also wonder what the writer would do if we faced a clearly just war, such as World War II. Would he still refuse to serve? Or is there simply never a just war in his eyes?
We now have an all-volunteer force, and it has real strengths. The men and women who sign up today are, by and large, professionals who want to be there. But it also has a serious weakness: too many of our fellow citizens have zero skin in the game. They watch wars on television the way they watch football. When the bill comes due in blood or treasure, it is always someone else’s kid. That detachment makes it easier to support endless foreign adventures with no personal cost. A modest lottery system might remind people that freedom isn’t free, but that is a separate debate.
Here is the reality most folks understand instinctively. The American public is like a flock of sheep. We are decent, productive, and largely peaceful. But there are wolves in the world, some foreign, some domestic, who would happily take what we have and subjugate or kill whoever gets in their way. We pay taxes and expect that money to buy protection. Our military, our police, and our first responders are the guard dogs, tough, loyal, trained Mastiffs and Great Pyrenees who are gentle with the flock but absolutely lethal when a real threat appears.
The letter writer is a member of the flock who has decided the guard dogs are the real problem. He wants to sit in safety and lecture the very people who make his safety possible. He is free to do that. But he should not expect the rest of us to pretend his choice was somehow nobler than the choice made by those who stepped forward when the country called.

Conscientious objection is a legitimate moral stance. Serving in the military is also a legitimate moral stance. What is not honorable is claiming the moral high ground for yourself while looking down on the men and women who actually stood the watch and risked their lives.
We can debate the wisdom of any particular war. But we should do it without turning the people who carried out lawful orders into villains. They deserve better. And so do the rest of us who sleep soundly at night because they were willing to stand between us and the wolves.
Support Independent Local Journalism — High Country Advocate was created as a real alternative to regional media that too often silences dissenting voices while taking sides in the political struggle. Producing in-depth, unflinching reporting like this series and others is expensive: servers, editing, research time, and legal review all add up quickly. If these articles have informed you or given you new perspective, please consider supporting HCA with a paid subscription — every subscriber helps keep this reporting strong and independent. 

