Listen, I’ve been around the cow pasture long enough to know a manure job when I see one. Back when I was fixing fence lines and dodging lightning storms, politicians still stretched the truth like cheap baling wire. But the 2024 election cycle? That was something else. Leading Democrats didn’t just criticize Donald Trump. They swore he was the Four Horsemen (War, Famine, Pestilence, and Death) all rolled into one rodeo knot. End of democracy. Dictator on day one. Nationwide abortion police. Grandma’s Social Security check snatched and sold for parts. Fascist boot camp by lunch on January 21, 2025.
Fifteen months later, here we sit in April 2026. Elections are still on the calendar. Rogue judges are still jamming up half the executive orders. Social Security checks are still clearing (mostly). And the Republic hasn’t turned into a theocracy or a police state. Yet walk into the cafe or yoga studio in Salida and you’ll still hear the same medium- to high-grade dread from folks who swallowed the 2024 panic whole. “He’s coming for your rights,” they mutter, eyes narrowed like I just suggested we let the wolves run the sheep. Which, come to think of it, is already happening. Colorado reintroduced wolves not long ago, and plenty of ranchers will tell you exactly how well that’s working out for the livestock.
The sky-is-falling crowd never quite admitted the sky stayed put.
Let’s refresh the memory, shall we? Kamala Harris stood up in Milwaukee and told the country Trump’s “extreme Project 2025 agenda” would “ban abortion nationwide” and “go after birth control.” Never happened. She said the same blueprint would “cut Social Security and Medicare.” Checks still arrive. She warned Trump intended to be “a dictator on day one.” He took office, signed a stack of executive orders, and the Constitution didn’t melt.
Joe Biden called Trump “the greatest threat to American democracy in our lifetime.” Nancy Pelosi said his reelection would hand the country over to authoritarian control. Hillary Clinton warned of outright fascism. AOC, Elizabeth Warren, and Chuck Schumer all sang from the same hymnal: this man would destroy the middle class, weaponize the Justice Department against his enemies, and turn the United States into a boot-on-the-neck dictatorship. None of it came to pass.
Not the nationwide abortion ban. Not the contraception crackdown. Not the senior-citizen starvation program. Not the suspension of elections or the martial-law jamboree. Aggressive conservative policymaking? Sure. Border enforcement, deregulation, Schedule F house-cleaning at the agencies. But the republic is still standing, lawsuits are flying in both directions, and nobody’s goose-stepping down Main Street.
Here’s the part that really chaps my undercarriage: they knew they were stretching it. Trump publicly called parts of Project 2025 “ridiculous” and said he knew nothing about it. Fact-checkers, even unfriendly ones, kept correcting the “Trump’s secret blueprint” line. The “dictator on day one” bit came from a single interview quip about using executive power on day-one priorities. The campaign turned it into a literal coup warning anyway. The press let them. Cable news and big-city papers ran the doomsday headlines like gospel, then shrugged when the apocalypse got postponed indefinitely. No corrections on page one. No “we may have overstated” editorials. Just on to the next dire warning.
That’s the pattern, folks. Scare the bejesus out of people, pocket the votes and donations, then ignore that their failed prophecy never came true. Once the lack of truth is exposed, either by direct fact-check or the simple passage of time, they ignore it and move straight to the next pretend emergency. Rinse. Repeat. The public gets indoctrinated with fear, then weaponized with it. Anger becomes identity. And when reality refuses to match the script, well, that’s when things turn ugly.
I’ve watched neighbors who used to argue over fence lines now refuse to sit at the same Thanksgiving table because one side still believes Trump was going to round up dissenters and impose a Christian nationalist police state. Challenge that worldview and you don’t get a debate. You get venom. Eyes glaze over. Voices rise. Anything that doesn’t fit the “Trump = existential threat” story is violently disregarded, facts bouncing off like hail off a tin roof. Their reality is so warped that they can’t even entertain the possibility they were sold a bill of goods.
And the funniest, saddest part? So many of the warnings were pure projection, what the Democrats themselves had already done or were doing.
They swore Trump would “weaponize the Department of Justice” to persecute political enemies. Yet the Biden-era DOJ brought multiple indictments against Trump while his opponents skated on everything from classified documents to riot-related charges. They warned Trump would “censor speech” and silence dissent. Meanwhile, the same crowd was coordinating with Big Tech to throttle stories about Hunter Biden’s laptop and COVID policy skeptics. They lectured us that Trump would “undermine election integrity.” Yet Democrats fight tooth and nail against basic measures to know who is voting and whether they are legally allowed to do so. Lawfare, venue shopping, and fundraising off felony mugshots became the Democratic party’s favorite new sport. They claimed Trump would “destroy democratic norms.” January 6 was awful, but two-tier justice and intelligence-community leaks sure didn’t look like norm-respecting behavior from the other side.
Now, with the supposed fascist crackdown nowhere in sight, they’ve rolled out “No Kings” protests to refocus and fan the flames. Protestors strut around acting like they’re taking some noble risk, bravely standing against tyranny. Nobody seems to notice how foolish they look when the much-feared fascist boot never drops. No mass arrests. No secret police. Just more theater.
The curmudgeonly truth is this: fear sells. Division pays dividends. And once a chunk of the public has been trained to treat every conservative policy disagreement as the second coming of tyranny, they don’t want to hear that the wolf never showed up. Admitting the panic was overblown would mean admitting they were played. Easier to double down, call the skeptic a MAGA cultist, and wait for the next manufactured crisis.
Around here in the high country we still value straight talk and a little common sense. We’ve seen enough blizzards to know the difference between a real storm and somebody yelling “avalanche” so they can sell you a shovel. The 2024 doomsday rhetoric didn’t end democracy. It just poisoned a lot of dinner tables and coffee-klatch conversations that used to be civil. The folks peddling the panic owe the rest of us a little honesty: own the exaggeration, quit changing the story, and let us argue policy instead of apocalypse.
Because if we keep letting leaders treat voters like frightened livestock, the real casualty won’t be democracy. It’ll be the neighborly trust that used to hold these mountain towns together. And that, friends, is a loss we can’t afford.
Support Independent Local Journalism — High Country Advocate was created as a real alternative to regional media that too often silences dissenting voices while taking sides in the political struggle. Producing in-depth, unflinching reporting like this series and others is expensive: servers, editing, research time, and legal review all add up quickly. If these articles have informed you or given you new perspective, please consider supporting HCA with a paid subscription — every subscriber helps keep this reporting strong and independent. 