President Donald Trump called affordability a “hoax perpetrated by Democrats” during a December 9 speech in Mount Pocono, Pennsylvania. The political blowback was immediate. But drilling into the economic data reveals something unexpected: Trump might be directionally correct about a manufactured narrative, even as Democrats ride the issue to electoral victories.
The economic data tells a clear story. Inflation sits at 3 percent—down from President Biden’s 9.1 percent peak in 2022 and identical to Biden’s final month in office. Black Friday 2025 saw retail sales jump 4.1 percent year-over-year, with online sales surging 10.4 percent. A record 203 million consumers shopped over Thanksgiving weekend. Same-store sales climbed 7.6 percent through November, according to Federal Reserve data.
These numbers reflect normal economic conditions, not crisis. Yet Democrats campaigned on affordability and won major November 2025 contests in New York City, Virginia, and New Jersey. The electoral success came despite economic measurements running in the opposite direction of their messaging.
Real affordability pressures exist but trace to different sources than the narrative suggests. Medicare Part B premiums jumped $17.90 to $202.90 monthly for 2026, the second-highest dollar increase on record. That increase consumes nearly one-third of the 2.8 percent Social Security cost-of-living adjustment. Colorado property taxes rose independently of federal policy. The housing market froze as 58 percent of Fannie Mae mortgages carry rates below 4 percent while current rates hover around 6.5 percent, creating a standoff where neither buyers nor sellers can afford to move.
Fed Chair Jerome Powell acknowledged Wednesday the housing problem exceeds his tools: “Many people have very low-rate mortgages from the pandemic period. It’s expensive for them to move, and we’re a ways away from that changing.”
The investigative conclusion requires examining what economic data actually shows versus what voters hear. Inflation at 3 percent is not a crisis—it’s approaching the Federal Reserve’s 2 percent target and represents normal economic conditions. Spending at record levels contradicts claims that Americans can’t afford basic goods. Unemployment remains low and wage growth continues.
Yet Democrats won three major November elections campaigning on affordability while these economic indicators ran in the opposite direction of their messaging. The disconnect isn’t between Trump’s position and economic reality—the data supports his “hoax” framing. The disconnect is between economic reality and electoral outcomes.
The actual affordability pressures affecting Americans trace to non-Trump sources. Medicare premium increases consume Social Security adjustments. State and local property taxes rise independently of federal policy. The housing market freeze results from Federal Reserve actions in 2020-2022 creating a cohort of homeowners with 3 percent mortgages who cannot economically justify selling when current rates run 6.5 percent. None of these factors appear in the political narrative about Trump-caused affordability crisis.
Trump’s vulnerability isn’t factual accuracy—the economic data validates his position. His challenge is that elections run on narratives rather than Bureau of Labor Statistics releases, and the opposing narrative proved effective in November regardless of underlying economic measurements. Whether that continues through 2026 midterms depends not on inflation rates or retail sales figures, but on which story voters believe about why their grocery bills feel higher even as they spend record amounts on Black Friday shopping.
Support Independent Local Journalism — High Country Advocate was created as a real alternative to regional media that too often silences dissenting voices while taking sides in the political struggle. Producing in-depth, unflinching reporting like this series and others is expensive: servers, editing, research time, and legal review all add up quickly. If these articles have informed you or given you new perspective, please consider supporting HCA with a paid subscription — every subscriber helps keep this reporting strong and independent. 