Rhys Williams works at Whole Foods in Fort Collins. He is 24 years old. Federal Election Commission records show he donated $73,752 through ActBlue in 2025—113 separate transactions to Democratic campaigns and committees.
A Whole Foods employee in Colorado earns $15 to $21 per hour. That translates to $31,200 to $43,680 gross annual income. After taxes: $24,336 to $34,070 take-home pay.
Williams donated 216% of his likely net income.
Colorado Secretary of State records confirm Williams exists. He registered as a Democrat on December 6, 2023. His address matches the FEC filings. The donations are real. The math is not.
James Quinn of Morrison presents a different problem. Colorado voter records confirm Quinn is a registered Republican. He owns Quinn Process Equipment Company. FEC records show he donated $23,492 through ActBlue—57 transactions to Democratic causes.
A Republican business owner sent $23,492 to the Democratic fundraising platform. Either Quinn secretly funds the opposition, or someone used his identity.
Judy Noerr of Westminster made 822 ActBlue donations totaling $798. She is 84 years old. VoterRecords.com shows Noerr has no voter registration in Colorado.
A non-voter made 822 political donations.
Peggy Cruder of Aurora made 1,788 ActBlue donations. She is 81 years old. Her records include 914 transactions of exactly zero dollars—voided contributions that leave an audit trail. The volume suggests automation, not an octogenarian clicking through donation forms.
These patterns are not unique to Colorado.
Investigative journalist James O’Keefe went door-to-door confronting elderly people whose names appeared on thousands of ActBlue transactions. A man in Annapolis allegedly made 12,000 contributions totaling $217,000 over three years. He denied knowledge. A woman in Annapolis appeared on 1,000 donations totaling $18,000. She said she gave “once in a while.”
O’Keefe visited Sonia Immasche in Fort Collins. Federal records attributed 57,138 donations totaling $234,000 to her name. Immasche, 78 and retired for two decades, told him she gives “$10 to $15 at most.”
President Trump ordered Attorney General Pam Bondi to investigate ActBlue on April 24, 2025. The memorandum cited “straw donors”—people whose identities mask the true source of contributions—and potential foreign money entering American elections.
Bondi was given 180 days. The deadline passed October 21, 2025. No report has been released.
Nineteen state attorneys general have opened separate investigations. Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton began his probe in December 2023. The House Administration Committee analyzed 200 million contributions and concluded ActBlue’s “general attitude towards fraud prevention is unserious.”
ActBlue now requires CVV codes for credit card donations—the three-digit security code that verifies physical card possession. The platform lacked this basic safeguard until investigators raised questions.
Seven ActBlue senior executives departed within three weeks in February 2025, including the organization’s last in-house counsel. No explanations were provided.
How does a grocery worker donate $73,752? Why does a Republican send $23,492 to Democrats? Why does a non-voter make 822 donations? Why does an 81-year-old make 1,788?
The records are public. The math does not work.
Support Independent Local Journalism — High Country Advocate was created as a real alternative to regional media that too often silences dissenting voices while taking sides in the political struggle. Producing in-depth, unflinching reporting like this series and others is expensive: servers, editing, research time, and legal review all add up quickly. If these articles have informed you or given you new perspective, please consider supporting HCA with a paid subscription — every subscriber helps keep this reporting strong and independent. 